The Power of a Strong Preferred Supplier List in Law Firm Recruitment

Today, We’d Like to Talk About a Different Kind of PSL…

Not Professional Support Lawyers this time, but the other PSL that plays a vital role behind the scenes in many law firm’s recruitment success: the Preferred Supplier List.

For HR and recruitment teams across London’s law firms, whether US, International or National, your PSL can make the difference between a seamless, efficient hire and a weeks-long scramble to fill a role under pressure. When time constraints, evolving regulations, or team growth create hiring pressure, your PSL should be more than a list of names, it should be a genuine network of trusted partners who understand your culture, your teams, and your pace of business.

But as law firms evolve, so should their PSLs. Are yours still serving you in the way they once did? Are your suppliers providing the right balance of communication, candidate quality, and market insight? Or is it time to reassess how that partnership really works?

​

Why Establishing a PSL Matters – Especially for Firms That Don’t Typically Use Agencies

Some law firms still prefer to hire directly and understandably so. Direct hiring provides full control over the process and messaging. However, as the market becomes more competitive and candidate-driven (particularly within business services), relying solely on internal recruitment can slow things down and narrow the talent pool.

Partnering with a select group of specialist agencies through a formal PSL strikes a valuable balance: it keeps recruitment controlled and consistent, while opening the door to broader networks, market insight, and time efficiency.

A well-managed PSL allows firms to:

• Control their brand messaging — only trusted recruiters represent your firm, ensuring consistency in how your roles and culture are presented.

• Reduce duplication — without a PSL, multiple agencies might contact the same candidates about the same role, which risks confusion and damages credibility.

• Save time — trusted suppliers already know your tone, processes, and expectations, so you spend less time briefing and more time interviewing the right people.

• Reach passive talent — agencies often have access to individuals who aren’t actively applying but would consider the right opportunity.

• Maintain compliance and consistency — with agreed terms, confidentiality processes, and DEI standards.

While hiring directly will always offer the most control, establishing a PSL creates a structured, transparent way to engage agencies, ensuring your brand is represented professionally and the recruitment process remains efficient, compliant, and effective.

​

1. Why a PSL Matters

A strong PSL provides consistency, compliance, and efficiency, key when hiring needs spike or time is tight. It reduces risk by ensuring every supplier understands your vetting, data handling, and DEI policies. When used well, it saves HR time and builds a trusted feedback loop between firm and recruiter.

​

2. What Makes a Good PSL Partner

It’s not just about sending CVs. It’s about understanding your firm’s DNA - the tone, culture, and expectations that make the right fit.

A truly effective PSL partner:

• Prioritises quality over quantity — they don’t flood you with CVs, they shortlist strategically.

• Communicates with responsiveness and honesty — sometimes saying no one’s right for this yet is more valuable than sending five unsuitable profiles.

• Offers added value — salary benchmarking, market movement insights, and competitor hiring patterns that help you plan ahead.

​

3. Are You Getting the Communication Balance Right?

Are updates regular and clear, or do they feel one-sided? Does your PSL provide real-time insight, such as market feedback and salary benchmarking, or only react when roles come up?

Firms that maintain two-way dialogue with their PSL suppliers get far more strategic benefit. Regular communication turns recruiters into proactive partners, not passive responders.

​

4. How to Get the Most from Your PSL

The best PSLs are partnerships, not pipelines.

To make the most of yours:

• Schedule quarterly reviews to discuss performance, challenges, and upcoming priorities.

• Involve PSLs early in new role briefs, they can help shape the search strategy.

• Share feedback candidly on what’s worked (and what hasn’t) so suppliers can refine their approach.

• Treat your PSL agencies as an extension of your HR team, they’ll deliver better results when they feel like part of your internal success story.

​

5. When It Might Be Time to Change It Up

Even the best PSLs need review. Signs it may be time to reassess include:

• You’re receiving too many CVs but not enough hires.

• Communication feels reactive or transactional.

• Suppliers seem out of touch with current market trends or your internal structure.

• The PSL hasn’t been reviewed in years and no longer reflects your evolving practice areas or team sizes.

A fresh look at your PSL can reinvigorate your hiring outcomes and ensure alignment with your firm’s growth strategy.

​

6. Big Agencies vs. Niche Specialists

There’s room for both, but it’s important to recognise their differences.

Larger agencies bring reach and resources, ideal for volume hiring, but they can sometimes lack the personalisation or deep sector insight that legal recruitment demands.

Smaller, niche agencies (like Pembury Legal) focus on long-term relationships, specialist expertise, and tailored service, offering consistency, flexibility, and in-depth understanding of your market.

The most effective PSLs strike a balance, combining broad coverage where needed with specialist partners who bring precision, personalisation, and true market insight.

​

7. Beyond the Marketing: The Real Work Behind a Good PSL

Strong PSL relationships aren’t built on who has the biggest marketing budget. They’re built on trust, transparency, and shared success metrics.

It’s about the grunt work, the detailed conversations, the hours spent understanding team dynamics, and the ongoing effort to refine searches until they’re right.

A great PSL partner doesn’t just help you hire. They help you plan, offering insight that shapes future workforce strategy and helps anticipate hiring trends before they become urgent.

​

Closing Thoughts

A PSL should never be a static list. It should evolve alongside your firm, adapting to new priorities, technologies, and business support needs.

If your PSL is perceived merely as a procedural necessity rather than a genuine partnership, it may be time for a mindset shift. The most forward-thinking law firms already recognise that recruitment agencies can be far more than a last resort, they can be strategic allies who understand the nuances of the legal market and work collaboratively to achieve long-term goals.

Because when your PSL truly aligns with your vision, it doesn’t just help you fill roles, it helps you build stronger teams, enhance culture, and future-proof your talent strategy.

#LegalRecruitment

#PreferredSupplierList

#LawFirmHR

#RecruitmentStrategy

#BusinessServices

#TalentPartnerships​